[Mpls] RE: Another DT restaurant closes

Michael Atherton athe0007 at umn.edu
Fri Oct 21 10:11:54 CDT 2005


Tim Bonham wrote:

> Dividing the US GNP ($11,750,000,000,000) evenly between the US 
> population(283,000,000) gives an income of $41,519 per person, or 
> over $297,000 for a family of four.
> 
> Hardly "poverty".  In fact, well into the middle-class range, 
> I would say.

This statement is so problematic, that it scares me to
think that anyone could possibly accept it at face value.  
First, if noting else, it's the GROSS National Product.  
So I'm assuming that you're also proposing to distribute debt
as well?  Not to mention that the two largest experiments in
Marxism have failed.  Perhaps you could give an example
of a society that successful equalized class levels and
incomes?

Michael Atherton
Prospect Park





More information about the Mpls mailing list